Down Payment Scenarios — $400,000 Home
Here's how different down payment amounts affect your monthly payment, PMI, and how long it takes to save (assuming $1,500/month saved at 4.5% APY):
3% (Conv. 97)$12,000$2,224$150$22,000~8 mo
3.5% (FHA)$14,000$2,250$133$24,000~9 mo
5%$20,000$2,201$100$30,000~12 mo
10%$40,000$2,097$65$50,000~26 mo
20%$80,000$1,994—$90,000~50 mo
Assumes $400,000 home, 6.75% rate, 30-year term, $10,000 closing costs, saving $1,500/month at 4.5% APY from $0. PMI estimated at standard rates.
Where to Save Your Down Payment
The right account depends on your timeline. Never put your down payment in stocks if you're buying within 5 years:
HYSA
4.5–5.0% APY
Best for down payment savings — liquid, insured, highest safe return
12-mo CD
4.8–5.2% APY
Slightly higher yield, 1-year lock-up — good if timeline is clear
I-Bonds
Inflation +
Inflation protection, 1-year lock-up, $10K/year limit
T-Bills (3-12 mo)
4.9–5.2%
Very safe, competitive rates, state-tax exempt
Stocks / ETFs
7% avg (risky)
Too volatile for <5 year timelines — avoid for down payment
Should You Put 20% Down or Buy Sooner?
The 20% "rule" was standard decades ago when PMI was very expensive. Today, with home prices rising and PMI being relatively affordable, the math often favors buying earlier with less down:
- Buy now with 5% down if home prices are rising. If homes in your area appreciate 4%/year, a $400,000 home becomes $432,000 in 2 years. The extra PMI cost (~$1,800/year) is less than the extra $32,000 you'd need for the down payment.
- Wait for 20% if the market is flat. In stable markets, the PMI savings from 20% down justify a longer savings timeline.
- Consider 10% as a sweet spot. Enough to get competitive rates, PMI cancels within 5–7 years through payments + modest appreciation, and the savings timeline is manageable.
- Use down payment assistance if eligible. Over 2,000 DPA programs exist — many offer $5,000–$25,000 in grants or forgivable loans for first-time buyers. Search downpaymentresource.com.